The Beach Club on Madison Avenue ★★

La Mer Beachfront Resort ★★★

The Dormer House ★★★

Marquis de Lafayette ★★★

Sandpiper Beach Club ★★★★

Montreal Beach Resort ★★★

"Very nice, very clean updated room. We were in room 301- so no view or balcony- but you could step outside and walk around and look at the water (which is across the street)-BUT people do walk by the front of your room, in front of the sliding glass doors, so if you don't want that, book room with a view- they have balconies and you cannot walk in front of them.Check in was a breeze and Diane was very efficient and informative. We only stayed 1 night, but chose not to go to the pool because we came on a Sunday, thinking it would be quiet and chill. The bar is right next to the heated pool and there was a band, so it was not quiet- nothing wrong with it- just not what we were looking for. Beach was gorgeous. They have a jitney that takes you to town and towels available that you can also take to the beach. Keurig, microwave and mini-fridge in each room as well as a safe and robes. Well-lit at night and felt safe walking to my room solo. AC worked wonderfully - I should have brought an extra blanket. Water pressure was a little weak but doable. Only negatives- beds were pretty soft and the pillows were terrible- bring your own."

ICONA Cape May ★★★

"The room is clean and bright, but it can only look at the sea from the side. Ctrip's resources are limited. In fact, there are many hotels facing the sea that can be booked. However, this hotel is small and beautiful, and the parking space is a bit tight."

Avondale by the Sea ★★★

Mahalo Cape May ★★