The Menhaden Hotel

The Menhaden and the staff are exceptional. Each one of the staff I interacted with was extremely attentive and helpful!

Overall great stay at the hotel! Definitely reserve pack and plays early if you need them. Also it’s how centrally located this is to other places in the area

We had a fantastic stay! The hotel goes above and beyond with thoughtful touches—snacks, chips, candy, fresh chocolate chip cookies and in the morning, yogurt with toppings, almonds, coffee, milk, juice, soda—so many nice options. The bed was incredible and unbelievably comfortable, and the pillows were just as amazing (and I’m very picky about pillows!). The staff couldn’t do enough for us. Aidan gave us such a warm welcome when we arrived, and Dan was terrific—when we texted him from the rooftop bar, he brought up a perfectly made old-fashioned for my husband. The rooftop itself is wonderful, with cozy fire pits and a great atmosphere. We even met another lovely couple while we were there. Even though we were only two hours from home, it truly felt like a vacation. I would absolutely come back, and next time I’ll definitely bring friends so they can enjoy it too

Great Hotel. The staff was wonderful helping with anything we needed. Rooms very nice and clean. I would highly recommend,

What a gem of a hotel! Everything about our stay was perfect and the team was so accommodating because we were traveling for the first time with our puppy. The hotel is centrally located, very well appointed with a galley that has breakfast and snacks all day, a gorgeous rooftop, all your beach gear for a day at the beach, and fantastic staff. We’d highly recommend it for couples, solo travelers, and families (and even puppies). It’s especially convenient if you’re a New Yorker and didn’t bring a car. You can walk to the beach and all around Greenport (or take one of their beautiful bikes). A big shout out to Mario and Aiden for making our trip especially delightful and memorable with lots of great recommendations.

The Menhaden always delivers. Mario and team look after every detail. The hotel is beautifully appointed and the hotel amenities make for a perfect stay. It’s a great getaway with a short walk from the train station.