We loved the beautiful setting and convenient to places. Ver yclean and the bed was the most comfortable.

Best resort in Islamorada! Great views, private beach, gorgeous property, lots to do on site! It's worth mentioning that you could always get a chair in the pool area or on the beach, huge plus for me!

Love this new resort in my favorite place in Islamorada They have made it a first class experience! Highly recommend.

Beautiful place and Staff was attentive.

We stayed at Three Waters Islamorada in early March 2025 in the Cove section, shortly after it reopened as part of a combined resort. It is now an extensive property; the pleasant but windy walk from the Cove to the end of the marina is a half mile. Room 7308, where we moved after concern about the unappealing view from 7202, was nicely designed inside and out. The main restaurant, Kindler, was not yet open; we did not eat at the other dining options that were open. Staff were friendly, eager to atone for some of the shortcomings still present at reopening. The room water bottles did not twist open and were dated 10-11-2024. We responded to the pre-arrival email from the concierge and got a “Permanently failed” message. The sink stopper was impossible to move. There were ants in the kitchen area in our 3rd floor room. And there was annoying music playing in the common and parking areas. The daily resort fee of $65 with taxes is, as elsewhere, a hidden charge that results in disrespect all around. We are thankful that some monetary relief was offered at checkout for these various inconveniences. The resort has potential, but we will be checking TA reviews for some upgrade commentaries before our next visit to Islamorada.

My family and I recently stayed at Three Waters Resort & Marina in Islamorada, and overall, it was a fantastic experience—truly a home away from home. The resort’s transformation from the old Postcard Inn is impressive, with its sprawling 15-acre oceanfront setting, vibrant island vibe, and plenty of activities to keep us busy. The staff were warm and welcoming, the beaches (especially Sunrise Beach) were a blast for the kids, and the Tiki Bar’s sunset views were a nightly highlight. Our room was spacious, clean, and had a cozy Keys-inspired feel, making it easy to unwind after a day of exploring. That said, a couple of things stood out compared to the Postcard Inn days. I was disappointed to find no feather pillows—something I’d gotten used to in the past. The bedding was comfortable enough, but those fluffy pillows were missed! Also, activities like kayaking and paddleboarding, which used to be free with the stay, now come with a charge unless bundled into specific packages. It’s a bummer to see that shift, though the resort fee still covers some perks like bikes and the water taxi, which we loved using to hop between properties. Despite those quirks, Three Waters won us over. The pools (especially the swim-up bar) were a hit, the marina added a cool boating vibe, and the food options—like Mercado Morada’s street eats—kept everyone happy. It’s not perfect, but it’s a place we’d return to for that laid-back Keys escape. Great stay, indeed!