Oyster Bay Boutique Hotel

We are profoundly disappointed in the way Oyster Bay Boutique Hotel managed our wedding booking. Despite multiple assurances that a contract was forthcoming, none was ever provided—despite our repeated and proactive follow-ups. This lack of follow-through ultimately resulted in a double booking, with our weekend being handed over to another couple who had secured dates surrounding ours. Even more troubling, when we expressed a willingness to match the other couple’s financial contribution, the hotel appeared to entertain the idea of reversing course—further underscoring a lack of integrity and commitment to prior discussions. It’s deeply disheartening that a venue entrusted with such a pivotal and emotional milestone would operate with such a transactional mindset. This experience reflects a troubling absence of professionalism, clear communication, and ethical consistency. For an industry that should be built on trust and thoughtful service, this was anything but. I cannot in good conscience recommend this venue to any couple seeking a reliable and respectful partner for their wedding.

Awesome Awesome customer service, good location and great room. Just wish I was there a little longer!

online, I wasn’t sure if the property was more like bed-and-breakfast or more like a hotel. The Internet cannot do it justice.. . I had to stop in my tracks and write this review because I owe it to the owners. The people who built this place care about their customers. It’s obvious in every corner because no detail was ignored. Every area is warm and comfortable and inviting.. When having a late night snack downstairs I felt like I was raiding my own kitchen. Stay here!